From: Lee Corbin (lcorbin@tsoft.com)
Date: Mon Apr 07 2003 - 22:48:37 MDT
Damien B. writes
> Lee Corbin re-wrote:
>
> >The data in the quote reads
> > Percentage of
> > Top Percent All Taxes Paid
> >
> > 1% 37%
> > 5% 56%
> > 10% 67%
> > 50% 96%
>
> By a strange coincidence, these figures are exactly the same for the
> proportion of brain surgeons working in the USA!
>
> Percentage of
> Top Percent IQ Brain Surgeons
> > 1% 37%
> > 5% 56%
> > 10% 67%
> > 50% 96%
>
> It's just so unfair to the clever, who get no rest at all, that the
> less intelligent half of the population should sit around on their
> duffs drinking beer and cleaning out restrooms and other idleness
> when they could be doing their share of the brain surgery!
To most of the people on this list, like you, there is indeed a
natural elite of the smart. I have no objection to this perception,
and even share it. But that's not the elite that Michael Dickey
was writing about, nor I above.
The "elite" that pays all the tax is mainly that segment of the
population who engage in the greatest amount of free economic
transactions with others, and this can include porn artists,
marijuana growers, and even insurance salesmen. Many of these
people do not need the narrow technical skills (or, on Bell Curve
observations, IQ) of brain surgeons, but instead most importantly
require the perception that if they work hard, and play by the
rules, then they'll get all that they deserve.
Every time that we weaken their incentives, as with the unfair
tax rules above, we place our entire world on a lower exponential
growth pattern, with severe consequences (in the long run) for
everyone.
Lee
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Mon Apr 07 2003 - 22:55:36 MDT