Re: Fightin' words (was Re: MOVIE: "What Women Want")

From: Gamma Pi (gammapi@newsguy.com)
Date: Sat Dec 23 2000 - 12:22:16 MST


The book Contact by Carl Sagan is IMO much better than the movie. It tries
hard to make the science believable. The movie though good was conceived as
a mass market movie so that believable science was not a requirement.

> >Uh oh -- I forgot one. "Contact". It may actually be the only OTHER
> >"Science SF" movie ever made, as well as a damned good "Social SF" movie.
> >The opening equence alone is worth the price of admission. (And yes, I
know
> >there are a couple of pretty terrible scientific gaffs in "Contact", but
they
> >don't go to the heart of the story . . .)



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b30 : Mon May 28 2001 - 09:50:39 MDT