>> Is the statement "all things are relative" a true statement? You see how
>> absurd such windage is? Relativism is incoherent. If rationality is not
>> wedded to truth then it is clearly irrationality.
>Reilly, all phenomenons are relative to the relativity of time and space.
>This relativism is true: In our experience is there only one time -- but
>if we send a atomary watch (A) with a space shuttle around earth and have
>an other similar runing atomary watch (B) on earth than there is a time
>difference between A and B after A has returning from space.
>If Einsteins proposal of general theory of relativity is true than every
>watching of phenomenons is relative to the location of the watching human
>in time and space -- and there isn't any sign that Einsteins general the-
>ory of relativity is wrong.
>Not every relativism is incoherent.
I'm coming into this debate late, so I appologize if my topics have already
been covered.
The argument of relativism vs absolutes is a very slipperey slope.
First I want to point out that asserting a position of an absolute frequently
leads to a fallacy. (Notice I didn't say "always" because my statement
would then be a paradox; I would be falling for the same fallacy.) (Humor: whenever
anyone starts out by saying "all" or "none" my initial gut reaction is to <in
my best Monty Python/Holy Grail voice>"run away!"</voice>) :-)
For example, the statements "all things are deterministic," or "nothing
is deterministic" both fall into that category. Empirical & experimental & experiential observation would
seem to indicate that many things are deterministic (eg classical physics).
Empirical & experimental & experiential observation would also seem to
indicate that there are some things that are not deterministic (eg quantum mechanics).
Since I utilize the pragmatic viewpoint, it seems to me that the approach to take is simply
"take the approach that produces the results you want." In the example above
this would mean that in some situations a "deterministic perspective" might be
more useful, and in some situations an "indeterministic" one might be more
useful.
I don't consider myself knowledgable enough about physics (at least
at the current time) to evaluate the merit of relativity in that area. I will
focus on relativity in ethics.
Going back to my previous point, if you say "all morals are relative" then
you just created a paradoxical conundrum. You would be using an absolute
statement to affirm relativity. An oxymoron. :-)
OTOH, if you accept that there are in fact absolute morals/ethics, then you come
up against the dificult problems of who determines those ethics/morals, and how are
they determined. The historic solution to this problem is to default to some
religious gibberish. However I doubt that many transhumans would find that solution
acceptable (I certainly don't.)
SOme people accept that these ethics should be determined through democratic
vote. I do not accept this as a solution because you almost always end up with a
minority who is then typically coerced into conformance (the altrernative frequently being
death or imprisonment). Since I believe that non-coercion/non-violence *must*
be a fundamental principle if the human race is to survive and prosper, I do not
accept this as a solution. If OTOH, democratic vote is not backed up by force
than the voting itself really isn't all that useful and sounds more like my solution
below.
"Demoacracy is the worst form of 'government' .... accept for all the rest."
-- Winston Churchill (single quotes are mine)
So my personal conclusion uses a combination of pragmatism and common sense.
I would use the phrase "there are no absolute morals/ethics *that I know of*; each
individual decides for themselves what is ethical/moral. Personally, since I like
pragmatic and anarcho-capitalist ideas (although I don't exactly
like using these or any lables - they are too constrictive), my personal ethics are
"do what works, as long as it doesn't stomp on the rights of others." (I refer to
"rights" in an anarcho-capitalist way - but that is an enitrely differernt topic.)
However the problem with the no absolute morals/ethics statement is that it leads to
the innevitable "so you believe that anyone can do anything to anyone else - plunder,
murder, rape etc.!!"
And my answer to that is "no
for practical/pragmatic reasons this ethical relativity needs to be moderated by some
sort of common, agreed upon limits within which trans/post human civilization can
exist (if you accept having plunder, murder, rape etc. you have no civilization - depending
on your definition; my definition of "civilization" doesn't include those things).
So what is needed is some sort of "working boundaries" from within which
that ethical relativism can exist. This would be sort of a "meta-ethics". Of course you
then run into the same problem again of who determines these "meta-ethics." (See
my reason above for why I do not accept democracy as a method of achieving this.)
It would seem to me that two logical base-components of such meta-ethics would be non-
violence/non-coercion and a willingness to allow competing ethics/morals and memes to
exist in the "marketplace of ideas". I think a good place to start for these "meta-ethics"
are the "principles of civilization" that are posted somewhere on
http://www.buildfreedom.com (of course these are just my opinions) Freedom seems to
be a "lowest common denominator" within which other value systems can exist.
A socialist community could exist as a subset within an "anarcho-capatalist world."
Typically, an anarcho-capatalist community would never be tolerated as a subset
under a socialist/communist/facist regime. There is historical evidence for this.
There are certain memes that clearly do not permit co-existance with other memes. For example, certain
sects of radical Islamic fundamentalism promote that all people must embrace their
meme. Otherwise they should be killed. This could be considered a type of "killer
meme" - a meme that attempts to not only promote itself, but destroy all others. (And
NO, I don't consider that trait inherent in the definition of a meme.) (So far as I know, the
term 'killer meme' was coined by Howard Bloom in his book "The Lucifer Principle.")
Contrast this with what I wrote above about an open marketplace of memes. Killer
memes are typically very dangerous. Although I don't know what the best way to deal
with them might be.
Since it is likely that there will always be competing memes, it is also likely that there
will always be competing ethics/morals - relative or not.
I don't claim this to be the best of solutions. I certainly don't have "THE" answer. As I
said at the beginning of my post, this is a dificult question. These are just some of my
thoughts, and one possible starting point for a solution. What better solutions can we
come up with?
Regarding the first 'posters' statement at the top of this message: "If rationality is not
wedded to truth then it is clearly irrationality."
In order to respond to that I would have to ask you what your definitions of "rationality"
and "truth" are. My
definition of "truth" is a 100% accurate perception of "reality." (And yes, I do believe
that there is in fact an "absolute reality," and that it is "out there". But I also believe
that everyone has thier individual "construction" or perception of "reality" which is
incomplete and can include incorrect information. Based upon my empirical
observations/testing I believe that certain aspects of this
"reality out there" are static, and that others are dynamic. No human or transhuman
that I know of has evolved enough to have an "absolutely" 100% accurate perception
of "reality" (ie omniscience). And since certain parts of this "reality" are changing
constantly this would have to be an ongoing process.)
Nietzsche's opinion was that since everyones perception of "reality" is merely an
approximation of that "absolute reality," all 'truths' or 'knowledge' are/is a form of 'useful fiction.'
A sort of a pragamatic self deceit. His opinion was that when these ideas or 'useful
fictions' stop producing desired results they should be thrown out and new "useful
fictions" should be created of adopted. Hence he came up wth the aphorisms like "question
everything" as tools to help with this. He also pointed out that these "useful fictions" frequently
become seen as dogmatic absolutes, even long after they have ceased being useful.
For example, this has occured in the field of physics. First you had Aristotles physics.
Then you had Galileos physics, but he was labled a heretic for quite some time, until
some of his ideas were finally accepted, and Aristotles rejected. Then along came
Einstein ... etc ...
Another possible future example: at this point in the evolution of "our"
(meaning human/transhuman) knowledge, many people
believe Einstein's idea that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. This
is reasonable based upon the information "we" currently have. But some future
information may "paint a bigger picture" about "the way things are". This new
perspective might then open up other new possibilities which we did not "see" before. Such
as traveling faster than the speed of light. (I hope so; the speed of light is too
slow :-)
One working definition of rationalsim: "using logic to make decisions based upon
empirical data and experiential results". How's that for a def? :-) Not the only or best
definition, but good enough for now.
So I would say that "rationality" IS wedded to the "truth." The problem lies in what you
consider to be "truth." Approximations are not black or white, they are grey. So things
are not so easily put into the "rationality box" or the "irrationality box" - depending on
the quality of your perceptions/information. You could call this the "argument from
Fuzzyness." (I would really recommend Kosko's "Fuzzy Logic" for more on this).
"So far as mathematics apply to reality, they are not certain. And so far as mathematics are
certain, they do not apply to reality." -- Einstein
(I'm quoting this from memory - I couldn't find the reference so, I may have it a little off.)
Feedback appreciated (no flames please).
Sin,
Jason
Temporary email address: PaR@NU-WORLD.com (new one coming soon!)
------ =_NextPart_000_01BD6526.18DD2270
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64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------ =_NextPart_000_01BD6526.18DD2270--