Manga Reality

From: Phil Osborn (philosborn2001@yahoo.com)
Date: Tue Jun 17 2003 - 20:31:04 MDT

  • Next message: Olga Bourlin: "Reasoning AI Experience"

    As the virtual worlds get more and more interesting
    and people start buying up real estate, artifacts,
    prileges, etc., it might be worth looking at an
    ongoing predecessor - Manga!

    I recently visited a Japanese coffee shop / book store
    and, noting a whole bunch of unbelievably cute slender
    young Japanese girls, all sporting the same hair
    styles, clothes, etc., all like something right out of
    a Manga fantasy novel, I asked the cashier (similarly
    atired) the following:

    "Does Manga drive fashion, or does fashion drive
    Manga."

    Once she understood the question, she replied that she
    thought that Manga drove fashion, which I had
    suspected. For those who are uninitiated to the Manga
    scene, the differentiating characteristic is simply
    that the text is integrated with graphics, as in a
    comic book. Manga, however, covers the entire gamut
    of literary expression, and must be taken - where it
    applies - as serious literature.

    To try to settle an issue of biology and culture that
    same weekend, I bought a couple of cheap XXX DVDs from
    a Japanese vendor at a local computer swap meet.
    Interesting. As I had surmised from other sources,
    Japanese/Asian men appear to be somewhat
    physiologically deficient in at least one area - at
    least wrt relative gross size... Nice to know, as a
    normally endowed Euro. (But they make up for it in
    energy, it seemed.)

    However, perhaps more interesting was the take on sex
    that seemed to prevail - admittedly with a small
    sample, but it does dovetail with other data nicely.
    While Euro/American women are generally portrayed as
    enjoying sex in the corresponding sort of videos, the
    Japanese women are invariably shown crying out in
    pain, and the relationship is clearly portrayed as one
    of power, with strong undertones of sadamasochism. I
    found it boring and tasteless rather than erotically
    stimulating, despite the fact that the women were
    quite beautiful.

    In fact, by comparison, the eroticism in the printed
    Manga is far more captivating. I got a couple of big
    boxes of Manga novels of all kinds by accident from a
    closing store recently, and made the error of starting
    to glance through them as I was loading them into my
    office. Two hours later.... I'm straining my eyes in
    the twilight still trying to make it through the door.

    From an objectivist standpoint, the printed Manga is
    art as it should be, romantic, stylized, architypal
    portrayals of life at its essense. The art is often
    truly beautiful, and the erotic scenes.... Well, I'll
    let the reader check it out.

    So, content rules. A static image on paper beats
    thousands of frames of motion video.

    I did note that the same vendors at the swap meet did
    have XXX Manga videos or "anime." However, they cost
    3X the live DVD price.

    __________________________________
    Do you Yahoo!?
    SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!
    http://sbc.yahoo.com



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Tue Jun 17 2003 - 20:40:54 MDT