[IRAQ/WAR/BIOETHICS]: finding a balance point

From: Robert J. Bradbury (bradbury@aeiveos.com)
Date: Sat Mar 29 2003 - 08:15:21 MST

  • Next message: Amara Graps: "Cato Institute celebrates Women's History Month"

    Since my previous comments with respect to when war
    might be a utilitarian necessity only seemed to draw a few
    (useful) offlist comments but Michael's recent comments on
    perhaps a fundamental incompatibility between Islam and
    [trans]humanity did stir the pot, I'm going to take another
    shot at this.

    Lets start with Greg's pointing out Shermer's perspective
    on cloning. A URL that works for me is:
    http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleID=00084EAF-2081-1E61-A98A809EC5880105

    Now lets take article 3 of his proposed laws of cloning:

    3. A human clone is to be accorded the dignity and respect due any member
    of our species.

    This is a critical value that must be dealt with in the evolution
    of [trans]humanity. Humanity doesn't even come close to providing
    other humans with "dignity and respect". We can cite examples
    from the Saddam Fedayeen (I would encourage some of the people
    on the list to consider whether we can even classify these people
    as "human") to simply the average person walking down the street
    in any of the more developed countries who is unaware of the large
    numbers of people in Bangladesh who are being poisoned by arsenic
    in their drinking water.

    The question becomes -- how does one deal with people void of
    any "dignity and respect" for others of our species?

    And then how are we to deal with expansion of the disparities
    between what one might consider "members of our species"?

    One can see the tip of the iceberg now in terms of wealth disparities
    but it is going to become much more significant when that evolves
    into intelligence or genetic engineering disparities. The cloning
    debate is but a melted drop on the tip of the iceberg compared
    with what seems possible.

    Robert



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Mar 29 2003 - 08:22:38 MST