RE: JP Barlow, Ph.D, Social Engineering

Jeff Dee (jeff@illusionmachines.com)
Wed, 25 Sep 1996 11:22:31 -0500


------ =_NextPart_000_01BBAAD3.D7F6FCD0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

>>>> = Ira Brodsky
>>> = Kathryn Aegis
>> = Sarah Marr
> = Shaun Russell

>>>>Throw out "black and white facts," and you throw out concrete knowledge.

>>>Cling to black and white facts, and cripple your ability to move
>>>beyond the edifice of whatever discipline forms your base of
>>>knowledge.

>>>Cling to black and white facts, and find yourself stranded on a
>>>static bit of earth as the universe moves its processes around and past
>>>you.

>>>Cling to black and white facts, and watch your children take off into
>>>the worlds of knowledge that you now seek.

>>Cling to black and white facts, and annoy an awful lot of very successful
>>scientists working with statistical quantum mechanics.

> Hmmm. I wonder if I could simplify this even more:

> Cling to facts...but also cling to the things other than facts.
>I think it would be a positively boring world if everything was facticious.

But that's the way that the world (er, universe) is. Or are you suggesting
the universe includes 'untrue' or non-existent things?

>Reality (and I hope no-one asks "But what is reality?") is that right now,
>we are human. That is a fact unto itself. Being human allows us to
>see around the facts. In fact <g>, that is one of the only qualities I
>adore in humans:
>the fact that we can see more than facts.

No, we cannot see more than facts. Our perceptions don't pop into
existence out of nowhere. Even hallucinations have some root physical
cause. At most, we can *imagine* (not 'see') non-existent things, and
we can draw erroneous conclusions about things we do see. Imagination
is a wonderfully useful tool, but I have a problem with characterizing it as
'seeing things that aren't facts'. It's nothing more than the ability to
construct hypothetical models - an ability that any thinking being will
need to have, not just us adorable humans.

-Jeff Dee
------ =_NextPart_000_01BBAAD3.D7F6FCD0
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64

eJ8+IiAQAQaQCAAEAAAAAAABAAEAAQeQBgAIAAAA5AQAAAAAAADoAAEIgAcAGAAAAElQTS5NaWNy
b3NvZnQgTWFpbC5Ob3RlADEIAQ2ABAACAAAAAgACAAEEkAYAKAEAAAEAAAAMAAAAAwAAMAIAAAAL
AA8OAAAAAAIB/w8BAAAASwAAAAAAAACBKx+kvqMQGZ1uAN0BD1QCAAAAAGV4dHJvcGlhbnNAZXh0
cm9weS5vcmcAU01UUABleHRyb3BpYW5zQGV4dHJvcHkub3JnAAAeAAIwAQAAAAUAAABTTVRQAAAA
AB4AAzABAAAAFwAAAGV4dHJvcGlhbnNAZXh0cm9weS5vcmcAAAMAFQwBAAAAAwD+DwYAAAAeAAEw
AQAAABkAAAAnZXh0cm9waWFuc0BleHRyb3B5Lm9yZycAAAAAAgELMAEAAAAcAAAAU01UUDpFWFRS
T1BJQU5TQEVYVFJPUFkuT1JHAAMAADkAAAAACwBAOgEAAAACAfYPAQAAAAQAAAAAAAACBzsBBIAB
ACgAAABSRTogSlAgQmFybG93LCBQaC5ELCBTb2NpYWwgRW5naW5lZXJpbmcAugwBBYADAA4AAADM
BwkAGQALABYAHwADADgBASCAAwAOAAAAzAcJABkACwADAAkAAwAPAQEJgAEAIQAAADFBODU1NTM3
OTUxNUQwMTE5OTU2MDBBMDI0Q0YxNDkxAMkGAQOQBgD4BwAAFAAAAAsAIwAAAAAAAwAmAAAAAAAL
ACkAAAAAAAMALgAAAAAAAwA2AAAAAABAADkAcPgqwP2quwEeAHAAAQAAACgAAABSRTogSlAgQmFy
bG93LCBQaC5ELCBTb2NpYWwgRW5naW5lZXJpbmcAAgFxAAEAAAAWAAAAAbuq/cAqN1WFGxWVEdCZ
VgCgJM8UkQAAHgAeDAEAAAAFAAAAU01UUAAAAAAeAB8MAQAAABoAAABqZWZmQGlsbHVzaW9ubWFj
aGluZXMuY29tAAAAAwAGEPcRfYkDAAcQqAUAAB4ACBABAAAAZQAAAD1JUkFCUk9EU0tZPUtBVEhS
WU5BRUdJUz1TQVJBSE1BUlI9U0hBVU5SVVNTRUxMVEhST1dPVVQiQkxBQ0tBTkRXSElURUZBQ1RT
LCJBTkRZT1VUSFJPV09VVENPTkNSRVRFS04AAAAAAgEJEAEAAABVBgAAUQYAADsOAABMWkZ1uNcJ
4P8ACgEPAhUCpAPkBesCgwBQEwNUAgBjaArAc2V07jIGAAbDAoMyA8YHEwKDEjMTD2Y0D3poZWzR
AyBEbGcCgH0KgAjPxQnZOxefMjU1AoAKgYMNsQtgbmcxMDMUIEELA2xpMTQ0AtFpfi0bgwzQG4ML
VRLyDAFjuQBAID4LRhQiDAFwA2AWdAWQBUA+H2AgPSAgSXJhIEIDYGRzfGt5Co8dDx4fHyQfkUsg
YXRocnkDoEFl/mcEACB3IV8ibx72H5EGEO0f0GgF0ArAciUPJhgoMuURwHUDoFJ1BBAWMSa/vx8E
IHUpDyYfJy8fYFQkYG5vB+AIYAVAIgJgANBrgiAAcGQgd2hpHxCEIGYA0HRzLCIx47p5CGAgJFEx
FQWgbgUAUxIAMnBrbjEQbAmAZ7xlLi0vLj8vTx8GQxtg8xqgM4BvIDGfMqM58wUCfwtQMnAzUQXA
AaADEDJQeXs5YgRgdjJwNd827zf/PvxiZTNQMgEkUDJwCYAGkGRpYzJwb2YyISRAZf888AXAQSAE
8AUgOSEycQWw5m0EIDvTYmER8EGCPS/rPj8/Tz40yCAtH0TPRd+/OI85nzqpG9AzJBHhbEGg/HN0
H9AyAAmAMTADoB/g90ivSb9Kzz5PACRAQVBMYPsyUEGCZQrAJFBMwAQgQNL9KxBpQhFD0TzSBCAy
UAQg/x7hQWArYQQgCsAIYDIBMfL/IKBPAE/fUO9R/x9gM1E1X99YP1lPS19MbzqpdyRAEbB3O8QR
sAMQZBegA6ABkGt/QXJBoAuAXzFbn1yvXb8+/UDSdwWwYfAEIEGRNMczgd8kQDNDNNFO8Anga1sf
Y8//ZN8e9l7fX+9W8jTQPIADkfBhd2Z1AyAXMFOzQhHxPIBzdWNWMm+haY9qn39rr0JxCfBTUE8A
BCBmsWt/bNID8FQxUyNPAEFQB0AgxHF1AHB0dW08wAWQ8xHAAwBjc2kPcd9y7x712XtWSG178EgB
SWahT0F/BcAGkHxBBaBvsDIQAJBt/UKhZjyBMkAEIEIBA6AEYP0XoDp333jvef97DGy3MpNaLoQA
YjFRB0BzbSBj/2zGQNJ+IRqgZwFA0QXAZ/H/A6CDtH//AFAsrYcfgQ8e1/5JiT+KQIknZW2Fkm2A
U6HPZrB9UkBgT7FwbwCQU1D9PPBsPIAG4AUQdXJmwnzSfUICeYWTYQEEIDKSQVBp3whgd7eL/4pA
IHVCMVFn8j4nVHRhEH4CaBFmdyAodwSQOvBU1ilVsHewSBBP7zwBF6AzQ3CgZzUwdkFs4W8gdVSb
C4CEwHUNsAQgJ3crEE8QClAnMTAFwDTQbrgtZXh00XShhYU/fxzbim8e9VJUADxTKDHyfFDYaG9w
MnA00C0CII+huyBABCAilUJBwphBIBegOaBTPyKYMmfkBRBnaLsFQDTRLJM/id9zbnePof2Y4Wh3
AABwSAEw4KKkH+D/MpJUwW0RVcFOwYcPjPKNL3ke9UJlbNKoY4RhFzB3/wQgK1BtAqTfpe9zbmjB
r19/jQ8e11alQNKDtHwxhpQg+DxnPjrwZ/N+QaGiQZH/QNICIJBhdrE8UQiQBCB8UPeu76//s+9k
ftFi0bmfs0/7HteoY3N/BrzPuq+OGTJ0/2fkp/F2cAOgaMF+s4Zafx7zIQ/BM05vOvDD5DTQsePv
xI+YgTvxoUByQWAFMJLgswYxvFBuJwVAj+BwYtt/nNVBYjFRQZE00YYhR/JF/36CEcAWQHCwC4BT
QcryEcAvPPGEkAeAovBvb/FwaH55AJB2csYFdnArUEfyQU8FQARgTwDIFiAqB3BheyTQQtAql1DI
kpXACeAn/5gwnJ+F0Dr0xgXD5WIAb4D/QQAo4KGhkvE0IwpAAJDK8v8BoDFChZWn8bxQaLJ8ItMT
/88TSCapM3x0b6GQYdGRb6L/bRAG8DrwhDKhAc+Sj8EDYH0CYGV3EHWjEbIyoQZxev9s0lOhVGHG
BdPibNOFpGfz95jRy1Iykyd8IpWyyJGR83/EmEDSPCnRBsrxnAG/Qnmfj+BA0XZUBGKEgCAtb0P7
PDbhc25+A47QbNJAYHVk/xZBxgVC0E9hbRHPgjrwyJL+aitQqbFWgbxRAaA7ob90+cWNLUoNwRZg
sh8srRbBAgDwoAAAAAMAEBAEAAAAAwAREAAAAABAAAcwMBaqC/uquwFAAAgwMBaqC/uquwEeAD0A
AQAAAAUAAABSRTogAAAAAAMADTT9NwAA8No=

------ =_NextPart_000_01BBAAD3.D7F6FCD0--