Re: Reincarnation, Was Tao of Physics - fun claptrap (was religionbashing)

Zeb Haradon (
Sat, 23 Oct 1999 15:59:10 -0700

I've always thought reincarnation was an incoherent idea. Even if it were true that when Napolean died, something in him drifted around for a few hundred years until finding its way into my body, that thing is surely not
"me", nor is it Napolean, and it would make little sense to say "I was
Napolean in a past life", seeing as this mysterious thing that passed fro him to me (our "soul"?) has no effect on my personality or memory. Perhaps, by amazing coincidence, a good percentage of the atoms in my brain also resided in the brain of George Washington at some point in his life. If this were true, I think it would be on the same level of significance as reincarnation claims.

Zeb Haradon
My personal web page:
Some "pyramid schemes" I take part in: