Re: Circular Crackpot Identity

Ian Goddard (
Mon, 16 Mar 1998 00:41:40 -0500

Anton Sherwood ( wrote:

>Ian Goddard wrote:
>> As I've shown many times, the definition of identity
>> "A=A" is the crackpot fallacy of Circular Definition:
>I don't see the word "identity" in the phrase "A=A", do you?

IAN: "A" is the identity. Would a dictionary
that defines what an elephant is be useful
if it read, "Elephant: elephant." ?

VISIT Ian Williams Goddard ---->