Re: A (Useful?) Simplification

From: Mike Lorrey (
Date: Fri Jan 04 2002 - 09:40:52 MST

Samantha Atkins wrote:
> Joe Dees wrote:
> >
> > Let's say that there are a hundred people on an island (let's call it Spaceship Earth); the majority, say 85, eat meat and vegetables, but realizing that their numbers are growing and that latrine space is overtaking cattle range and farmland, a few a
re working on ways to get our eggs out of a tiny basket before we all die of overpopulation-induced pollution and starvation. Let's say that the other fifteen have sworn fealty to a murderous Thugee ideology, and the only people they will not kill are th
eir own. What are the 85 to do?
> Actually, the minority eat meat and vegetables and consume most
> of the resources and wealth, of course they arguably produce
> much of it too. One option is to create more resource and
> distribute them more broadly. And also it might be good to eat
> less meat so not so much habitat is consumed feeding cattle. :)

Actually, this is a false assertion. Muslims are not vegetarians, nor is
most of North and South America, Europe, Africa, and much of Asia. The
primary concentration of vegans are in India and China, which represent
only 1/3 of the human race. Since that one third has the highest rate of
reproduction as well, the smarter option is for the vegans to stop
screwing like rabbits.

> Of course there is no 85% fine people who are protective and 15%
> who are murderous. It is highly artificial.

Yes, the murderous percentage lies closer to 0.5-2% in peaceful times,
but in many instances, propaganda campaigns can quicly boost that
percentage to a majority of the population, especially when there is a
large surplus of males.

> > 1) Hunt down and convert, or, failing that, kill the 15 so that all may live their lives unendangered and those working on liberation may continue.
> > 2) Join the 15 to avoid being murdered.
> > 3) Blithely ignore the 15 and hope that one's own number does not come up.
> > 4) Try to understand the killers as members of an alternative yet equally valid lifestyle and attempt constructive and nonjudgemental dialogue with them.
> > 5) Assert that the 85 deserve such a fate because of real or imagined historical wrongs and await their fate with a sense that an incomprehensibele (or maybe comprehensible, but these would most likely convert) divine justice was being meted.
> >
> > I stand squarely with alternative #1. I see Samantha as embracing alternatives #4 or #5 or perhaps a syncretism of the two.
> That is very dishonest. I do not claim that killers are of an
> equally valid lifestyle. I do claim and am quite correct in
> this that the terrorist have at least some claims of wrong-doing
> that should be examined on their own merits regardless of the
> source. Where we are in the wrong and can improve things we
> should in the interest of greater peace and well-being for
> working toward liberation. But that doesn't mean we condone
> terrorism in the least or do not punish it.

Funny, Samantha, are you not one of the people who sincerely believe
that two wrongs do not make a right? In such case, it is rather
disengenuous of you to assert that just because a terrorist has been
wronged in the past (or people s/he has never met in his life has been
wronged) that this somehow justifies their commission of wrong.

> And I most certainly never said or implied (5). My interest is
> in getting to "liberation" (Singularity) with as many of our
> fellow sentients on board as possible. I think you can get more
> on board by addressing real grievances even while ending
> barbaric acts of terrorism of all kinds. I believe you will
> get more people on board by welcoming more people on board
> whenver you can without inviting your destruction.
> Is that clear enough?

Crystal. Fortunately I, and many others here, are not so motivated to
drag every other human kicking and screaming into the singularity. Some
are simply dead weight, ballast, who are working actively against the
singularity and they will need to be excised from the global body if we
are to reach the goal.

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 13:37:32 MST