Re: [IRAQ] RE: Name Calling vs. Ad Hominem

From: Samantha (samantha@objectent.com)
Date: Mon May 12 2003 - 14:59:56 MDT

  • Next message: Party of Citizens: "Re: The Nanogirl News~"

    On Wednesday 07 May 2003 10:26 pm, you wrote:
    > Just to open up a can of worms... how do people now feel about the
    > war, given that the reason for going to war in the first place has
    > turned out to be bunk (well, lies actually, I guess). If we could
    > wind back time to before it happened, would you have still
    > supported/opposed it?

    Still oppose. I don't believe the end result in Iraq is going to be
    pretty. Sure, it would be nice if they became a western style
    democracy. But I don't believe the majority of the people have the
    necessary prior conditions for that to happen. The most likely
    outcomes are:
    1) long time occupation with attendant costs and dangers;
    2) an eventual theocractic state;
    3) another "strong man" dictator.

    None of those outcomes seems to me to justify the costs and other
    negatives directly and indirectly involved in pursuing this course of
    action.

    The one place where I have some doubt is the somewhat Michavellian
    perspective of a true US imperialism desiring a base of operations in
    the region and/or ultimate control of the oil (in Saudi Arabia also
    eventually by this logic). That always has been the only very like
    explanation I saw for our actions. No, I don't consider it at
    justification.

    - samantha



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Mon May 12 2003 - 15:04:26 MDT