Harvey Newstrom wrote:
> > > Suppose my copy and I want to move the table
> > > to one side.
> >
> > Both of you point to your left and see the
> > other pointing to your right – no divergence.
>
> I never claimed a divergence in what they see.
> I claimed a divergence in which wall they point
> to. They are not pointing toward the same wall.
Says who? Prove to me that it's not the same wall. Prove to me that these are two different people.
> > Agree? You can't even strike up a conversation
> > – you're talking to yourself.
>
> Pointing doesn't require talking.
> They point. They disagree.
They both point to their left, they see both of their copies point to their right, where's the disagreement?
> > So you decide the walls are different and to
> > check you write your name on the left-hand
> > wall.
>
> Why are you ignoring my test and rewriting one
> of your own? I agree that you can invent a test
> that doesn't prove you wrong. I am more
> interested in your response to my test which
> does prove you wrong.
BM