Re: what if microsoft disobeyed the breakup?

From: phil osborn (
Date: Wed Jun 07 2000 - 23:19:56 MDT

>From: "Ian Field" <>
>Subject: Re: what if microsoft disobeyed the breakup?
>Date: Tue, 6 Jun 2000 21:48:59 -0700
>Billy Brown wrote:
>| Claims that the "wrong" product has won out in a free market are
>| among supporters of the products that lost, but they almost invariably
>| out to be incorrect.
>This leads into "history is written by the victorious". 30 years from now,
>I wonder what the general perspective on MS and its competitors will be....
>For my part, as an advanced application designer, I *know* that my world is
>a better place thanks to the folks at Redmond. I do understand concerns
>related to anti-competitive, innovation-destroying practices, but the DOJ
>has definitely jumped the gun in this case. The market would, on
>a lack of new innovation, find/create it elsewhere. We were in the midst
>a computing revolution, and are bound to take a technological step
>due to this bungle. The economic impact could also be enormous...
Funny, most of the professional developers I have known over the years
consider MS/DOS - Windows to be an unbelievable kludge. And what about the
market itself? It was specifically Bill Gates who pushed us into the
software marketing model that still prevails - where the software developer
gets a few pennies on the dollar, while most of the money goes to marketing,
and the end-buyer really has little clue as to product suitability or
reliability. Read Steven Levy's "Hackers." We could have had a model more
like the LINUX - open-source, peer-reviewed system, where lousy software is
caught before it ever made it to the shelf, and the money mostly goes
directly to the creators, and solid products cost a fraction of the Windows
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Jul 27 2000 - 14:12:50 MDT