Science: Cosmos' Primordial Song

From: Vita-More, Natasha (
Date: Thu May 11 2000 - 15:34:10 MDT

The Cosmos Was Alive With the Sound of Matter
                                by K.C. Cole (LA Times, May, 2000)

When the universe speaks, astronomers listen. When it sings, they swoon.

That's roughly what happened late last month when a group of astronomers led
by Caltech's Andrew Lange published the most detailed analysis yet of the
cosmos' primordial song: a low hum, deep in its throat, that preceded both
atoms and stars.

It is a simple sound, like the mantra "Om." But hidden within its harmonics
are details of the universe's shape, composition and birth. So rich are
these details that within hours of the paper's publication, new
interpretations of the data had already appeared on the Los Alamos web for
new astrophysical papers.

"It's stirred up a hornet's nest of interest," said UCLA astronomer Ned
Wright, who gave a talk to his colleagues on the paper the next week.

So what is all the fuss about? Why are astronomers churning out paper after
paper on what looks to a lay person like a puzzling set of wiggly
peaks--graphic depictions of the sound, based on hours of computer analysis?

Because there's scientific gold in them there sinusoidal hills.
The peaks and valleys paint a visual picture of the sound the newborn
universe made when it was still wet behind the ears, a mere 300,000 years
after its birth in a big bang. Nothing existed but pure light, speckled with
occasional subatomic particles.

Nothing happened, either, except that this light and matter fluid, as
physicists call it, sloshed in and out of gravity wells, compressing the
liquid in some places and spreading it out in others. Like banging on the
head of a drum, the compression of the "liquid light" as it fell into
gravity wells set up the "sound waves" that cosmologist Charles Lineweaver
calls "the oldest music in the universe."

* * *
Then, suddenly, the sound fell silent. The universe had gotten cold enough
that the particles, in effect, congealed, like the salad dressing left in
the fridge; the light separated and escaped, like the oil on top.
The rest is the history of the universe: The particles joined each other to
form atoms, stars and everything else, including people. "The universe was
very simple back then," said Lange. "After that, we have atoms, chemistry,
economics. Things go downhill very quickly."

As for the light, or radiation, it still pervades all space. In fact, it's
part of the familiar "snow" that sometimes shows up on broadcast TV. But
it's more than just noise: When the particles congealed, they left an
imprint on the light. Like children going after cookies, the patterns of
sloshing particles left their sticky fingerprints all over the sky. The
pattern of the sloshes tells you all you need to know about the very early
universe: It's shape, how much was made of matter, how much of something

The principle is familiar: Your child's voice sounds like no one else's
because the resonant cavities within her throat create a unique voiceprint.
The large, heavy wood of the cello creates a mellower sound than the
high-strung violin. Just so, the sounds coming from the early universe
depend directly on the density of matter, and the shape of the cosmos

Astronomers can't hear the sounds, of course. But they can read them on the
walls of the universe like notes on a page. Compressed sound gets hot, and
produces hot splotches, like a pressure cooker. Expanded areas cool. Analyze
the hot and cold patches and you get a picture of the sound: exactly how
much falls on middle C, or B flat.
What they've seen so far is both exciting and troubling. The sound suggests
that the universe is a tad too heavy with ordinary matter to agree with
standard cosmological theories; it resonates more like an oboe than a flute.
Something's going on that can't be explained. The answers may come when an
even more ambitious probe launches into space later this year.
Lest you think these sounds are music only for astronomers' ears, consider:
The same wrinkles in space that created the gravity wells that gave rise to
the sounds also blew up to form clusters, galaxies, stars, planets, us.

This e-mail, and any attachments thereto, is intended only
for use by the addressee(s) named herein and may contain
legally privileged and/or confidential information. If you
are not the intended recipient of this e-mail, you are
hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or
copying of this e-mail, and any attachments thereto, is
strictly prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in
error, please notify me by replying to this message and
permanently delete the original and any copy of this e-mail
and any printout thereof.
For additional information about Chadbourne & Parke LLP
and Chadbourne & Parke, a multinational partnership, including
a list of attorneys, please see our website at

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Jul 27 2000 - 14:11:06 MDT